9 Ways to Get More Product Reviews and Increase Social Proof

Want to go get some lunch? There’s that new Thai place that opened a few months ago.

If you’re like most of us, your first instinct was to reach for your smartphone or fire up a browser to check the Yelp reviews.

Online reviews matter to us, and they matter to our customers. Nobody wants to spend money or precious time on something that’s going to result in a terrible experience. Not when they may be able to stop it.

In this post, we’re going to talk about social proof, namely what it is and why it’s important. Then, we’ll show you how to get product reviews on your website with 9 excellent tips and tools you can put into action right now.

Let’s get started.

What is Social Proof?

Social proof is a marketing tool rooted in our very human desire to belong. It includes things like reviews and testimonials, celebrity endorsements, and influencer marketing, among others.

Not only do we assume that we will become accepted members of a certain group if we have a specific item that they all have, but the item becomes more desirable when people we respect have it.

Social proof helps ease the minds of consumers and convinces them that purchasing your product will solve their problems.

Sometimes it even happens by accident. Like the time Emma Watson was spotted wearing a scarf with Scottie dogs on it by Crumpet Cashmere.

celebrity influencer

The scarves were sold out of stores within the week.

Want more information on social proof? Check out this article on how to use social proof to increase conversions.

Why Reviews are Vital for Social Proof

Simply put, shoppers trust reviews. Because of that, reviews are great for boosting conversion rates. In a survey conducted by Search Engine Land, they found that 88% of consumers make purchases from eCommerce sites with primarily positive reviews.

The author of the review also makes a difference. Reviews written by a “verified buyer,” “power buyer,” or as the result of a free sample or giveaway carried more weight with shoppers than other reviews.

Quick TipYou’re probably going to want a review moderation system in place on your site to help you filter out the reviews that are unqualified, not useful, or that just don’t make sense for your product.

9 Ways to Get More Product Reviews

Given how much shoppers rely on reviews you’d think that they would put more value on writing their own, but on average, they just don’t. 92% of consumers read online reviews, but only 6% end up writing them.

Related ContentSocial Proof Statistics: Powerful Facts That Will Help You Boost Your Brand

There are several things you can do to make it easier for customers to leave reviews and encourage them to do it, so let’s get into the details, shall we?

1. Make it Easy to Leave a Review

The easier you make it for customers to leave a review on your products, the more likely you are to actually get reviews. People aren’t going to go 4 levels deep on your site and then search for their product in a database in order to leave a review.

Take a cue from Beardbrand and make your reviews easy to find and easy to leave. Every product page has a section for reviews:

how to encourage customers to write reviews

You can do this with an app like Yotpo Social Reviews. See a couple more review management tools in #5.

Alternately, if you’re using WordPress, you can make a user review form with WPForms. This option may be more cost-effective, plus you can use the plugin to build contact and other forms on your website.

2. Display Your Reviews on Your Website

As you can see from the Beardbrand image above, they include their reviews on their website too. This serves a few purposes.

  • Lots of social proof. Other shoppers can see that people are enjoying this product.
  • More original content is great for SEO and rankings.
  • Shoppers can share reviews, ask questions, and mark other reviews and helpful or unhelpful.

If you’re asking for reviews, share them on your site. What else were you going to do with them, anyway?

If the reviews are particularly glowing or entertaining, share them on social media or highlight them in some way. And, definitely give a shout out to the customer.

Don’t forget, there are probably some awesome testimonials about your company on social media already.

You can easily pull reviews from Twitter and display them on your site with a plugin like Smash Balloon.

smash balloon twitter feed pro plugin

Smash Balloon’s Custom Twitter Feeds Pro lets you seamlessly integrate a Twitter feed into your website. The best part is that it gives you the ability to create a feed of tweets that mention your account or use your branded hashtag.

display twitter hashtag feed with smash balloon

This is the perfect way to show off the love your customers have for your business and encourage your website visitors to tweet about you too.

3. Send Purchase Follow Up Emails

Post-purchase email requests for reviews have about an 8% response rate, which makes them the best way to get reviews.

To get the best response, try to send your review request email within a week of the purchase to take advantage of those good feelings that shopping releases. ? Also, according to research done by Yotpo, you’re likely to get your best response on Saturday, so keep that in mind.

increase customer reviews

New to email marketing? Here’s our step-by-step guide to running an email marketing campaign.

4. Use Incentives to Increase Customer Reviews

Coupons, discounts, and other rewards are great ways to encourage your customers to leave reviews. And, incentives also have the added bonus of encouraging repeat sales.

Loyalty programs are a great way to track and distribute your incentives. If you have a loyalty program in place, you can incorporate points for reviews and sharing reviews on social media.

Contest entries are another great incentive that you can offer in exchange for a review.

And don’t forget that social mentions can be pretty cool rewards too. Just don’t forget to tag the customer.

how to get more online reviews

A quick aside: incentives are a great tool to increase customer reviews and a fine eCommerce marketing strategy overall, but make sure that you’re not just rewarding the positive reviews. We know, nobody wants negative reviews, but we’ll talk about how to deal with them in a minute.

5. Use Product Review Tools to Manage Reviews

There are quite a few product review tools available to help you manage your reviews. Whichever eCommerce platform you use, you’ll be able to find one that works for you.

Let’s talk about a few of them.


how to get product reviews on your website

Kudobuzz helps you collect reviews from customers in a few different ways:

  1. Sending out post-purchase email requests
  2. Collating posts and reviews from Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Google+, and Yelp
  3. Creating broadcast links that you can send to request reviews

The content is then displayed on the Kudobuzz dashboard and you can decide what you want to use where.


increase customer reviews

Yotpo is a review management solution that really shines in its analytics and reporting. You can use the reporting to make data-driven decisions to improve marketing strategy, generate reviews, and get quality traffic.

Product Reviews by Shopify

how to improve online reviews

Product Reviews by Shopify is perfect for those of us who don’t have coding knowledge but still want a great looking product reviews feature on our eCommerce sites.

Customers can engage with you and with each other within the product reviews, making it possible for you to respond to reviews. Your customers can even ask each other questions about the fit and feel of the product, which can result in increased social proof.

6. Make Reviews Count

We’ve already talked about incentives; people like getting something for giving something. One of the things that people get from Amazon for their reviews is recommendations. Amazon uses your reviews to later show you other products that you may like.

Basically, you’re reviewing things to help future you find more things to buy. ?

7. Include a Call-to-Action on Physical Materials in Each Order

If you include paper invoices or other marketing materials in your shipments already, you can create and include a call-to-action with a QR code. Then, use WPForms to create a mobile review form to capture reviews. When the customer uses the QR code from their phone, they’re taken to the form and can submit a review.

Not sure how to get them to scan the QR code? Learn how to create the perfect call to action here.

8. Post to Social Media

You can also use social media to get more reviews. Just include a link to a product’s review form in a post and ask your followers for a review.

Or, you could show off your snazzy new reviews on social media to encourage other followers to submit their own!

share review on social media

9. Pay Attention to Negative Reviews

You may think that the best thing you can do with negative reviews is to ignore them, but it definitely isn’t. Here’s a good process to follow for negative reviews:

  1. Apologize.
  2. Tell the upset customer how to contact you.
  3. Explain how you’ll make it right.

If you get everything solved and everyone’s happy, ask the customer to write a new review. If you’ve handled everything professionally and compassionately it’s entirely possible that you’ve gained a lifelong customer from a formerly bad review.

That’s it! Now you have 9 great ways to get more product reviews on your website and increase social proof. Take a look at this list of social proof software tools you can use to make it ridiculously easy.

Both are great ways to boost conversions, but if you’re looking for more, be sure to check out our beginner’s guide to conversion rate optimization or these awesome ways to increase your conversion rate throughout your sales funnel.

If you want some inspiration for ways to highlight your own customer reviews and testimonials, have a look at our own testimonials page. After that, we’re sure you’ll want to become one of our happy customers, so go ahead and do that too. ?

Jacinda Santora
Jacinda Santora is a writer specializing in eCommerce and growth marketing. She prides herself on her ability to make complicated things easier. When she isn't writing you can find her daydreaming about campervans, drinking coffee, and listening to podcasts.

Add a Comment

We're glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that all comments are moderated according to our privacy policy, and all links are nofollow. Do NOT use keywords in the name field. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation.