21 Content Marketing Mistakes the Experts Really Regret

Last updated on


21 Content Marketing Mistakes the Experts Really Regret

Are you worried about making a content marketing mistake that tanks your content strategy? You should be, because content marketing is a crucial part of attracting and retaining your customers, so getting it wrong can be costly.

One of the best ways to avoid harming your reputation and revenue is to learn from the best. That’s why we reached out to 14 content marketing experts and asked about the worst content marketing mistake they’ve made or seen.

As you’ll see, even the experts can make catastrophic content fails. By the end of this roundup, you’ll know the worst content marketing strategies to avoid. These content marketing tips will help you create a content strategy that works.

Recommended Resource Need to jumpstart your content marketing results? Get more traffic and conversions with our Ultimate Guide to Content Marketing in 2018.

Let’s kick off with a cautionary tale from Andy Crestodina about a situation where he made a content marketing mistake that hurt his reputation.  As Kuno Creative points out, public speaking is content marketing, too, and although it relates to a presentation, the lessons at the end relate to any type of content marketing.

As you’ll see, with all content it’s essential to:

  • Avoid misleading your audience about your topic
  • Deliver what you promise
  • Focus on creating content that you’re really expert in

Read on to see how you can avoid the content marketing mistakes Andy Crestodina made:

1. How Andy Crestodina Crashed and Burned

Andy Crestodina: I’m on my way to Las Vegas to speak at a conference. I spoke there last year and I was honored to be the top rated speaker.

So this should be no problem, right?

The organizers want me to cover analytics again. But since I did that last year, I want to give attendees something new. So a few weeks before the event, I suggest a change in the topic: Google Tag Manager. The programs have already been printed, but they can still change it on the website.

So we should be good, right?

I’m not really an expert at Google Tag Manager, but I recently wrote a popular post on the topic and I got a pro to review my slides in advance. Everything looks good.

So this should go fine, right?

I hit the stage in a room of about 60 people. My opening statement is a reminder that the printed programs aren’t correct. I’m covering a different topic, so if there’s another session you want to see, don’t feel bad walking out. The energy in the room drops and a few people leave. Others just look annoyed.

andy crestodina content marketing fails

This isn’t a great start.

As my presentation gets going, I know I’m bombing. This isn’t going well. I feel like I betrayed them. I also can tell that a few people are a little bored. They know this stuff. Others are confused. This stuff is kind of technical.

This is getting worse.

So I speed up a bit to get through to some of the more valuable points. I also just wanted this to end and stop wasting people’s time. Luckily, I have a few friends in the audience. They look sympathetic. Finally, it’s time for Q&A. No, I can’t really answer the best questions because I’m outside my area of expertise.

Crash. Burn. The disaster is complete.

It’s over. And it’s an almost complete failure. I get a beer with a buddy who tells me it wasn’t that bad. But it was. Here’s why:

  • The printed description didn’t match the session. That’s a sin at conferences.
  • I gave a new presentation to a big room. Never a good idea. Always test new presentations at smaller events.
  • My topic was on the outside edge of my knowledge. Even though the presentation was accurate, I wasn’t able to add value during the Q&A.

The feedback. Here’s what attendees said. Read it for yourself:

This was garbage all around… I don’t believe that Andy actually knows what he is talking about despite writing a book on it… This was one of the biggest disappointments of all the sessions… Too fast… Simply didn’t happen. There wasn’t a presentation. And this was a big one on my list…

How can I fix this content marketing mistake? I really can’t since it was an event. But I’m sharing the story. It’s a cautionary tale. Please don’t do what I did. You’ve been warned!

Andy Crestodina is a co-founder and the Strategic Director of Orbit Media, an award-winning 38-person web design company in Chicago. He is also the author of Content Chemistry: The Illustrated Handbook for Content Marketing. Find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter as @crestodina.

Now, some of our experts reveal the content marketing mistake they most regret.

2. Not Starting a Blog

Heidi Cohen: My worst content marketing mistake? Despite writing a bi-weekly Actionable Analysis column for ClickZ since 2004, I put off starting my own blog. Once I decided to start blogging, I wrote for 6 months before opening my writing to the world. Guess what happened: Very little.

heidi cohen content marketing mistake

Lesson: Just. Do. It.

Heidi Cohen is the Chief Content Officer of the award winning Actionable Marketing Guide, focused on social media, content and mobile marketing. Find her on Twitter as @HeidiCohen.

3. Failing to Capitalize on Traffic

Jeff Bullas: My biggest content marketing mistake wasn’t a one-off but a strategic error. The mistake? Not taking advantage of the traffic the content was generating in building my email list.

jeff bullas content marketing

It cost me over 100,000 subscribers. That is a big mistake.

I fixed it by creating pop-ups that captured emails and built my email list. Today I have over 160,000 on my email list.

Jeff Bullas is an entrepreneur, blogger, author, marketer and international keynote speaker and works with businesses to optimize their digital brand with content, social media and digital marketing. Follow him on Twitter as @jeffbullas.

4. Having the Wrong Offer

Michael Brenner: The worst content marketing mistake I made was early on in my launch of a content hub for SAP. We realized we needed to fill a gap in top of funnel content.

We planned and executed against that gap, thinking readers would start converting to product pages.

Oh boy, were we wrong. NO ONE converted for months until we realized we needed a mid-stage offer strategy as well.

Michael Brenner is a globally-recognized keynote speaker, author of The Content Formula, and CEO of Marketing Insider Group. Michael teaches leaders to champion their people and the ideas that make the greatest impact. Find him on Twitter: @BrennerMichael.

5. Missing Lead Generation Opportunities

Ann Smarty: My biggest content marketing mistake was not optimizing for leads for years. I started a blog in 2010 and I hadn’t been doing anything to build up a good email list until probably 2015.

I did have a Feedburner RSS subscribe link and their email capture form but I wasn’t doing anything else. No calls-to-action, no emailing my list to keep them engaged, nothing.

ann smarty content marketing mistake

Just a couple of years ago I started converting my blog traffic into leads:

  • I set up a Mailchimp account to manage my list.
  • I exported Feedburner subscribers and added them to my Mailchimp account.
  • I used different calls-to-action (popups and on-site email forms) to engage different users depending on how they are using the site. OptinMonster is a great tool for that.

But when I think about years of traffic I lost, I shudder.

My advice to anyone looking to start a blog would be to think about lead generation even prior to launching. Don’t miss a single visitor coming to your site!

Ann Smarty is the Brand and Community manager at InternetMarketingNinjas.com as well as the founder of MyBlogU.com. She is the former Editor-in-Chief of Search Engine Journal. Follow her on Twitter as @seosmarty.

6. Ignoring SEO

Barry Feldman: I was an SEO unbeliever. Or ignoramus.

See, all bloggers struggle to build an audience in the early going, so I’m not going to go so far as to say if you learn the essentials of search it becomes a cakewalk. However, when I finally opened my eyes and learned the SEO ropes, my blog took off far faster.

barry feldman content marketing mistake

I learned so much about how to create content that ranks, I wrote a book, SEO Simplified for Short Attention Spans. I mention that not only to plug my book, but to stress that you need not become a world-class SEO nerd. You simply need to understand how to create and optimize content so it earns traffic from Google.

Barry Feldman is the founder of Feldman Creative, a boutique agency that specializes in content marketing strategy and execution. He’s the co-author of new book on personal branding, The Road to Recognition. Find him on Twitter as @FeldmanCreative.

7. Working with the Wrong Agency

Erika Heald: A former employer was trying to create a new category, and I’d drafted a plan for proprietary research to support those efforts. Our agency came back with a proposal that we couldn’t afford.

I wasted a lot of time trying to convince them there had to be another way to get the research done without spending over $100k. When they weren’t able to come up with a more affordable option, I reached out to a friendly analyst firm.

Erika heald content marketing fail

I was able to work with them on proprietary research and a webinar, at a third of the cost the agency had proposed. And when our contract with them was up, we replaced the agency.

Erika Heald is a San Francisco-based marketing consultant and freelance writer. She focuses on helping technology and specialty food startups define their content marketing strategy to drive lead generation and customer loyalty. You can find her on her blogs erikaheald.com and erikasglutenfreekitchen.com, or hosting the weekly #ContentChat Twitter chat.

8. Thinking Content Marketing was a Myth

Ileane Smith My biggest content marketing mistake was thinking that the term content marketing was a myth.

Boy, was I wrong.

I think the first time I heard the term content marketing was way back in 2011, not long after I launched Basic Blog Tips in 2010. It wasn’t until I started listening to This Old Marketing, the podcast from Joe Pulizzi and Robert Rose, that I began to wrap my brain around the concept and its true meaning. Even today I continue to listen to the podcast; it’s one of my favorites!

ileane smith content marketing fails

Yet the strange thing is, the more I listen, the more I understand that content marketing isn’t right for me.

Before you stop reading, let me explain. If you take a look at this description found on the Content Marketing Institute website you’ll find these words: “valuable, relevant, and consistent content”.

Well, over the last couple of years, I’ve only managed to fulfill two out of three on this list. Yes, my content is valuable (at least I think it is), and it’s certainly relevant, but when it comes to consistency I give myself a 6 out of 10.

I know, it’s a bitter pill to swallow. But you know what they say – admitting you have a problem is the first step toward overcoming it.

Joe Pulizzi will be the first one to tell you that if you aren’t going to be fully committed to content marketing, then you might as well not even try to use it. You have to be all in!

What about you? Can you honestly say that you meet all three requirements? I sure hope so. But if you are still a little rough around the edges like me, follow the lead of people like Robert and Joe for guidance and when you’re ready, dive in.

Here are a few more content marketers to learn from: Mark Schaefer, Jay Baer, Syed Balkhi and Wil Reynolds.

Ileane Smith is a Blogger, Podcaster, YouTuber and Social Media Diva! She runs Basic Blog Tips and does weekly live streams on her YouTube channel. Find her on Twitter as @Ileane.

But as well as experts’ own content errors, they’ve also seen businesses make costly content marketing mistakes. Here are the content errors you ought to avoid:

9. Being Too Promotional

Michael Brenner: The biggest content mistake I’ve seen other companies make is to make the content promotional.

michael brenner content marketing mistakes

Use your content marketing to publish 100% completely customer-focused content. Then nurture those readers with offers for deeper engagement. Eventually you can send them product offers. But most brands start promoting their products too soon.

10. Not Understanding the Audience

Barry Feldman: The common denominator of content marketers that fail to achieve their goals is a lack of understanding of their audience. They write about their products or whatever their agenda is.

barry feldman content marketing mistakes

Your agenda has to be educating, entertaining and inspiring your audience. You’ll only succeed by seeing things through their eyes.

11. Starting with the Product

Debra Jason: You’re unclear on how to deliver your message. Therefore, it’s not resonating – it’s repelling your prospects.

Don’t write copy that starts with the product/service. Customers don’t buy products; they buy what the products do for them (i.e., benefits, solutions). Your goal is to catch readers’ attention long enough for them to want to stop and read all of your content (or watch your video).

debra jason marketing mistakes

What do you DO to make your content compelling and inviting?

Begin with the concerns of your reader. Tell him/her “what’s in it for me?” (WIIFM). As a writer, create a picture in your mind of your readers – their lifestyle, their wants/needs, their pains or frustrations. Then, identify with them, put yourself in their shoes and write.

Some ways to do this are:

#1. Focus your headline on the single strongest benefit you can offer your reader. The goal of your headline is to get them to read the next line. So, if your headline doesn’t catch attention – you lose your audience. You want people to see your value.

#2. Promise something magnificent BUT do not lie. Don’t make a promise you can’t keep or you’ll lose the reader. Keep in mind that BAD news travels faster than good, so keep your readers happy.

#3. Evoke interest by:

  • Using SHORT, SIMPLE sentences to start out with. CLARITY is extremely important.
  • Writing TO people (not AT them).
  • Encouraging people them to read more by making your content easy on the eyes. If your paragraphs (or your sentences) run really long, you risk losing your reader.

#4. Touch on emotions. People react emotionally. So let your words touch on people’s emotions.

Professional speaker and author of the award-winning book, Millionaire Marketing on a Shoestring Budget, Debra Jason has been a professional copywriter for close to 30 years. Discover more about Debra at WriteDirection.com and DebraJason.com, or follow her on Twitter: @debrajason.

12. Getting Stuck in a Content Rut

Barry Feldman: Far too many content marketers are one-trick ponies. They don’t allow their blogs, hubs, vlogs, podcasts — whatever their sweet spot is — to grow and cover more ground with a greater variety of media. My post, 33 Dependable Sources to Get Content Marketing Ideas, was written to teach “stuck” content creators how to better understand their audience and uncover useful topics.

13. Neglecting Keyword Research

Ann Smarty: Unbelievably, I see more and more businesses neglect keyword research. They either lack an in-depth analysis or lack integrated approach. Keyword research should be integrated into everything you do: Video marketing, blog posts, customer support “Help” pages, “About” pages.

ann smarty content mistakes

Keywords are not just for rankings. They help you understand what your customers are searching, and hence analyze the demand and optimize the pages for better user retention. Keywords help you address customers’ needs better on your website pages and thus build audience, leads and sales.

I recommend using Serpstat to analyze keywords and search engine result pages. I like how they let you dig deep into keyword lists, and analyze how difficult it would be to rank for any keyword based on the competition.


Here’s a quick tutorial on how to use Serpstat to discover keywords and here’s one more tutorial on organizing keywords by intent to create a solid keyword strategy.

14. Having No Plan

Two of our experts cited lack of planning among the biggest content marketing problems. Here’s what they said:

Joel Klettke: Generally, the worst and most common content marketing mistake I see is companies who don’t have any kind of plan, rhyme, research or reason behind their content. They blindly chase trends or write to a keyword set without any further thought to how pieces link together or connect to their overall funnel.

Content marketing is not the process of shooting out as much “relevant” content as you can; every piece should have a purpose and a goal. There should be calls to action in your pieces, invitations to value, some greater purpose to your publishing than just publishing on its own.

joel klettke content marketing mistakes

Avoid this problem by learning to think in funnels. WHY are you creating a piece? What’s the goal? What is the goal of the person who will read it? How can you stretch the value of that piece out by repurposing it, or connecting it to other opportunities to learn or convert?

If you don’t go in with a plan, you might as well flush your cash down the toilet.

Joel Klettke is a conversion copywriter and CRO consultant at Business Casual Copywriting, where he’s helped clients like HubSpot, WP Engine and InsightSquared turn more visitors into paying customers. Follow him on Twitter as @joelklettke.

Erika Heald: The worst content marketing mistake I see marketers making is jumping in and creating content without a plan. Taking time to develop a content strategy, including robust buyer personas, gives you the foundation you need for an effective content marketing plan. Without it, you’re just engaging in random acts of content.

erika heald content marketing quote

15. Getting the Publishing Frequency Wrong

Gail Gardner: The worst content marketing mistake I see small businesses making is related to publishing frequency and content on their own blogs. They need to think about the goal of their blog and what their audience would want.

Personally, even if I love them, I do not want to hear from a small business more than once a week at most. If you publish too often or send too many emails, your audience will start tuning you out.

gail gardner content marketing mistakes

Don’t publish less than once a month or people with a typical memory may flag your email messages as spam. And finally, publish what makes sense. That might be writing about your products or making gift suggestions or sharing case studies.

Figure out who your target audience is, what they want, and what you want them to do. Then publish between once a week and once a month what they would be interested in that moves them in the direction you wish.

Gail Gardner is the Small Business Marketing Strategist who founded GrowMap.com. She can be found as GrowMap on all major platforms. You can find her on Twitter as @GrowMap.

16. Failing to Promote

Andy Crestodina: The most common content marketing mistake isn’t the content. It’s the marketing. People write something, add an image and hit publish, then go on with their day thinking that they did a good job.

This isn’t marketing.

andy crestodina content marketing mistakes

If you publish but don’t promote, no one is going to find, read or share your article. Or almost no one. Here are the analytics for a blog post that was published, but not promoted. There were a total of 19 visits after it went live. You can almost hear the crickets…

crestodina content marketing analytics

The fix? Never create a piece of content without a plan to drive traffic to it. That means aligning it with a keyphrase and topic that people search for. Or collaborating with influencers who may share it. Or sending it to an engaged list of subscribers who will love that subject line. But at least as much effort into promotion as creation.

“Post and pray” is all content, no marketing. And it doesn’t work.

17. Focusing on Quantity over Quality

Jayson deMers: I think the worst mistake I see is marketers focusing on quantity, rather than quality content. There’s this perception that more articles in circulation are going to lead to more followers and more activity, but that’s just not the case.

A few years ago, Moz and BuzzSumo ran an analysis that showed the vast majority of content never gets a single link or share, but a minority of content — the best of the best — attracts tons of links and shares.

What’s especially frustrating is that producing a greater quantity of content will give you better results — but in the short-term, and with nowhere near as much potential as producing higher quality content.

jayson demers content marketing quote

The fix is straightforward; spend more time on each piece you produce. Include more details, be more concise, rely on different mediums, link to higher quality sources, present fuller arguments, and write in a clearer, more audience-friendly way.

It’s more difficult and more costly, but it’s definitely better to have one phenomenal article than a hundred throwaway pieces that nobody wants to read.

Jayson DeMers is the founder & CEO of AudienceBloom, a Seattle-based content marketing & social media agency. You can contact him on LinkedIn or Twitter: @jaysondemers.

18. Using Flawed Buyer Personas

Carolyn Frith: Many buyer personas are cobbled together based on internal thinking (a.k.a. making stuff up). In a rush to launch a content marketing program, sales and marketing teams discuss their customers, decide what they think is important to them, and base personas on their consensus.

carolyn frith content marketing mistakes

The problem? These personas end up bearing a heavy imprint from those who speak the loudest in the organization. They have zippo input from those who really know what’s going on — customers!

Inevitably, when imposter personas guide the way, they lead content strategies astray. Organizations end up investing in anemic content that fails either to attract buyers or to move them step-by-step through the buying journey.

Key takeaway?

Unless you talk to customers, there’s no way to know where they turn for information, or what triggers them to prioritize and solve a problem. The purchase barrier your salespeople cite ad nauseam is price, but the reality is usually more complex. The bottom line is that company associates don’t know what they don’t know. And that is dangerous.

Carolyn Frith, Executive Director of Content Strategy and Creation for NuSpark Marketing, aims to rid the world of snore and bore B2B copy. Get her e-book: How to Conquer 5 Common Content Marketing Problems. Find her on Twitter as @carolynfrith.

19. Creating Content Dead Ends

Heidi Cohen: The most consistent problem content marketers make is creating content dead ends.

Specifically, marketers get visitors to a piece of content or communications and, even better, some get readers to take the next step such as signing up for emails or downloading content.

heidi cohen content marketing quote

BUT content marketers leave readers without offering another on-ramp to interconnected content or contact. In their minds, the marketers think that the next action is clear to the reader. Like drivers they need content GPS to find other content or action.

Content dead ends are easy to fix. Look at your articles, landing pages, responder emails and welcome emails. Offer your readers content off ramps to other related content except on pages where you need to focus them on taking an action.

Note: This work can be done as you create new content and update older content.

Here’s an example of how you can add content on ramps to your content:

Content on ramps 1

20. Forgetting about Reciprocity

Nancy Harhut: Content marketers forget about the Principle of Reciprocity.

Behavioral scientists have proven that when someone does us a favor, we feel compelled to return it. Content marketers can provide that favor by serving up consistent, on point, useful information to their audience, and in return, they can enjoy resulting business.

However, very often that goal of consistent, on point information is ignored in favor of getting out something – anything – to meet the deadline.

Instead of regular information centered around a specific topic, they publish a hodgepodge of unrelated articles, videos, infographics, etc. with little relation to each other or an established theme. This provides little value to their target market, and no reason for that market to feel a sense of reciprocity.

nancy harhut content marketing

To correct this mistake, content marketers need to identify their niche or area of expertise, and then create and post a steady drumbeat of content that supports it. They need to provide topic guidelines to employees who generate content, and review any submissions against them. This approach will deliver regular value that will then trigger the Reciprocity Principle.

Nancy Harhut is passionate about the impact of behavioral science on marketing. Companies seeking an added advantage tap her for consulting, creative direction and content development. Reach her at [email protected] and follow her on Twitter: @nharhut.

21. Giving Up

Jeff Bullas: One of the biggest content marketing mistakes I see people and brands making is not persisting at consistent content creation.

jeff bullas content marketing

You need to think about content marketing as a long term digital asset building play. According to Bill Gates “Most people overestimate what they can do in one year and underestimate what they can do in ten years.”

Over time content will build search engine authority, traffic and trust.

Play the long game.

Now that you know the biggest content marketing mistakes the experts regret, you’ll be able to avoid them to create a good content marketing strategy of your own. Check out these clever content marketing examples for inspiration.

Check out our email marketing guide for tips on winning customers with your content.

Don’t forget to follow us on Facebook and Twitter for more in-depth guides and expert roundups.

Disclosure: Our content is reader-supported. This means if you click on some of our links, then we may earn a commission. We only recommend products that we believe will add value to our readers.

Add a Comment

We're glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that all comments are moderated according to our privacy policy, and all links are nofollow. Do NOT use keywords in the name field. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation.

11 responses to “21 Content Marketing Mistakes the Experts Really Regret”

  1. Heidi Cohen Avatar
    1. Sharon Hurley Hall Avatar
  2. Anne Wayman Avatar
    1. Sharon Hurley Hall Avatar
  3. Lori Avatar
    1. Sharon Hurley Hall Avatar
  4. Cyrus Edwin Avatar
    1. Sharon Hurley Hall Avatar
  5. Yoo Need More Jodi Avatar
    1. Sharon Hurley Hall Avatar
  6. Riya Mahajan Avatar

Popular Posts

Connect with us:

Start Getting More
Leads & Sales Today
with OptinMonster!

Popups work, and you can get started for a few bucks a month. What are you waiting for?

Create and launch smart capture forms
today in minutes. What are you waiting for?

In only 7 months, we added more than 95,654 names to our email list using OptinMonster’s Exit Intent™ technology. We strongly recommend it!

Michael Stelzner - Best Lead Generation Tool

Michael Stelzner

Founder Social Media Examiner

I hate popups, so I was hesitant to try one on my site. But the results from OptinMonster exit-intent popup speak for themselves. I doubled my subscription rate immediately without annoying my users. I haven’t had a single complaint. My only regret is that I didn’t start using OptinMonster sooner. I can only imagine how many subscribers I could have added to my email list! If you have a blog, then I highly recommend you start using OptinMonster. I’ve researched them all, and it’s the best in market.

Michael Hyatt - WordPress Lead Generation

Michael Hyatt

New York Times Bestselling Author Platform: Get Noticed in a Noisy World

Exit-intent popups have doubled my email opt-in rate. When done right, you can see an instant 12% lift on driving sales. I highly recommend that you use OptinMonster for growing your email list and sales.

Neil Patel - WordPress Popup Plugin

Neil Patel

Founder QuickSprout